President Cyril Ramaphosa has faced and survived a series of political crises and dilemmas since assuming office. Police Minister Senzo Mchunu was suspended from his department for alleged links to police interference and misleading Parliament. If proven this could be obstruction of justice at the highest level of power. At the Presidency Budget Vote debate in parliament political parties such as the uMkhonto We Sizwe (MK) and the Economic Freedom Fighters called for Mchunu’s dismissal.
Ramaphosa tabled the Presidency budget on Wednesday, which detailed the Presidency’s spending plans and priorities for the year. Ramaphosa, in his speech, said that for the country to effectively tackle its challenges, it needs to build a capable state with institutions that are resistant to corruption or interference. But MK Party parliamentary leader, John Hlophe, questioned this, saying Ramaphosa has failed to punish those implicated in corruption and interference in his Cabinet, like Mchunu. KwaZulu-Natal provincial Police Commissioner, Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, alleged that Mchunu interfered in investigations related to the political killings task team. “Other ANC ministers who have damning allegations levelled against them are simply moved to different portfolios. This inconsistency reeks of selective morality. It shows that protecting your faction is more important to you than protecting the people of this country.”
Ramaphosa has always dealt with any political or legal scandal that has come his way with utmost maturity. The President is right to argue that the country has to build a capable state with institutions that are resistant to corruption or interference, however Ramaphosa should lead by example and reinstate those independent institutions that oversaw prosecution of the powerful such as the Scorpions Directorate of Special Operations (DSO) under the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). However, it is profoundly ironic that the MK party led by none other than former President Jacob Zuma is the one accusing Ramaphosa of corruption. Then again, the allegations against Mchunu can raise the hairs on the back of your neck. Ramaphosa for his part may not have the right to dismiss Mchunu until he is proven guilty. The Evidence should be examined.
Ramaphosa’s decision to place Mchunu on leave of absence has sparked strong opposition from various political parties who demand Mchunu’s immediate removal. The Economic Freedom Fighters and uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party have also threatened to challenge the decision in court. However, presenting the Presidency Budget Vote in Parliament on Wednesday (16 July), Ramaphosa said while the allegations against Mchunu are serious, “they are also untested.” “It is therefore necessary that we establish the facts through an independent, credible and thorough process so that we can ensure accountability and safeguard public confidence in the police service,” he explained. The President said it was therefore “strange” that some have strongly opposed the establishment of a commission of inquiry, which he announced on Sunday (13 July).
“Some have said that I should take immediate punitive steps against the Minister on the basis of untested allegations. Not only would this be unfair, but it would create a dangerous precedent. The commission should be allowed to do its work,” he added.
Ramaphosa may have found himself in an awkward position. He is right to create a Commission of Inquiry that will examine the conduct and actions of Mchunu. The intentions of the MK Party pressing for Mchunu’s ousting should be considered carefully. Are they using this scandal as an excuse to weaken Ramaphosa’s hold on office? They could try to force a vote of no confidence to unseat him. This could lead to the dissolution of parliament and another general election. The MK may be under the impression that they can win. Another matter is the infighting happening between current MK leader and former State President Jacob Zuma and his deputy, John Hlophe. The latest focus on Ramaphosa could be seen as a way for the MK to maintain its unity.
Ramaphosa and the process of justice is being undermined in this manner. The law needs to take its course. The Commission of Inquiry needs to look at the evidence implicated against Mchunu and deliver its verdict. The police minister has been suspended until then. Due process should be followed.
Article written by:
Yacoob Cassim
Journalist at Radio Al Ansaar
